Hey Everyone!From my last post, it is kind of apparent that I didn't really like the book "Friend Me". So, I switched books. I am currently reading a book called "Jay's Journal", written by anonymous but edited by Beatrice Sparks. It is about this student who makes straight A's, high GPA, perfect kid. He makes the wrong people and eventually discovers Satanism. He kills innocent kittens, slays bulls and drinks their blood, and many other awful things. Eventually, he commits suicide. I have read its predecessor "Go Ask Alice", a very controversial book also written by anonymous yet edited by Beatrice Sparks. Both are rumored not to be true stories, while Beatrice Sparks claims otherwise.
I decided to do a little research to find the root of the controversy. Well, it turns out that a lot of people don't believe her books are actual diaries (as stated on the front of the books) and are mainly influenced by fictional events. Beatrice Sparks is a psychiatrist who deals with troubled teenagers when she isn't writing/editing. She claims herself to be "Dr." Beatrice Sparks, but there is no actual proof and no found records of her doctorate degree. When she was asked about this, she gave very vague details. If you were already doubting her, this was not a very good fighting argument.
Many people believe that her books are not written by actual teenagers because of the language. Not the literal language as in English or Spanish, but as in age language (a teenager talks differently than a senior citizen). In "Go Ask Alice", the writer (supposedly a teenager) uses very large words, like the kind that would be on a spelling test and words expected to be used in a formal paper. Most teens would use words like those when required, but not in a diary only meant for her eyes only. Also, all of her books have underlying moral tones that imply "always listen to your parents" and "never do what everyone else is doing". If a teenager was writing in her diary and is always agreeing with her parents and not giving into peer pressure and ends up in the situations that they do, then that is just plain strange. Every kid thinks they are the smartest thing to hit this planet at one point or another. Most of the characters in the books are where they are due to peer pressure. And then to be saying "don't do it just because everyone else is" is so contradictory.
In "Go Ask Alice", the girl who wrote it goes on for four pages about her drug experience when someone slipped LSD into her drink at a party, yet only talks about her only true love breaking her heart for two paragraphs. That is 1/3 of a page!!! It seems like something like true love would be a pretty important factor in one's life, especially if they broke their heart and one needs to vent about it. Also, there is almost no he-said/she-said in the diary, something to be expected in any 15-year-old girl's conversations.
Every single person in the book who is involved with drugs with their described home life seems to come from a broken home and a dysfunctional family. It seems kind of ironic, doesn't it? The ending of the book states that 3 weeks after finishing the diary, the girl commits suicide by overdosing on drugs. Later, in an interview, Beatrice states that she did not commit suicide but died of unknown causes. If she changed the ending, the most important part of a book like this, then what else did she mess with?
In the back of her book "Go Ask Alice", it actually has text that says, “This book is a work of fiction. Any references to historical events, real people, or real locales are used fictitiously. Other names, characters, places, and incidents are the product of the author’s imagination, and any resemblance to actual events or locales or persons, living or dead, is entirely coincidental.” That is actual proof of her fictional inserts. But that is only one book, so we have no proof of her doing this to her other books. This hasn't been publicized very much, though, because "Go Ask Alice" is one of the most controversial books in the 20th century, not due to its fictional inserts, yet because of the heavy mentioning of drugs and other bad influences. It has been temporarily banned from many libraries through the years, so the book actually has a history.
The book is still listed under "non-ficion", despite what has been uncovered. I believe that the public partially doesn't want to believe that the book is fake. Now onto "Jay's Journal". The book is the "diary" of a boy named Alden who is a perfect kid and all that, turns to Satanism (as I mentioned earlier), and ends up committing suicide at age 16. The mom of Alden decided that "Dr." Beatrice was the person to give her son's journal to, so she turned in her son's journal to be published. After it was published, though, Alden's family was horrified because the majority of the book was not true! She said that Beatrice had made up several false entries and that most of the stuff said in the book was stuff that had never happened. Beatrice's response was that she got a lot of the information from interviews with Alden's friends.
So, what do you think? Are the books what they are said to be (real), or are they just a hyped-up lie to teach teens how to act? Do you think that this information should be more publicized to show that a lot of this doesn't actually happen? Should the morals be left to the parents to teach? Please comment your opinion!
-Favs
Sources:
(although Wikipedia isn't a great source since people can edit it, I decided it was a good starting place to see a general overview.)
(Snopes is usually a good, reliable website to find fact from fiction. Generally, they have the correct information.)
(I have never heard of LinaGoldberg.com, but it had the same information that the other two websites had, so I assumed that it was correct, although that probably isn't the best thing to do. Also, it was mainly facts about the books.)